As many of you know the All-Star break is coming up and voting ends tomorrow for the MLB All-Star game. No longer is the game a glorified exhibition game as it now determines home-field advantage for the World Series. We have compiled our list of players we think will make the team as well as have another blog coming after the rosters are picked to talk about snubs and who should/shouldnt be starting.
Starting with the American League we begin with the Catcher position. This year there are a couple of guys swingin the bat well but I believe Joe Mauer will be the starter. Currently in 1st by over 1.4 million votes (over Jason Varitek), Mauer is very deserving of starting as he has contributed in all areas for the Twins.
At 1st Base its a little more interesting. Kevin Youkilis and Mark Teixeira are the top vote getters but you could make a case for both Miguel Cabrera and Justin Morneau. I think Youkilis gets the nod for the start as he has been more consistent this season, while Tex has been up and down.
At 2nd its a four man race when, in reality, it should be a three man race (no offense to Robinson Cano fans). Ian Kinsler is tops in votes and started out on a tear, and Dustin Pedroia has been solid, but Aaron Hill should be 1st in votes, not 4th. This is one case where I would argue that fan voting is ridiculous. Aaron Hill has the best numbers and deserves to be starting but, due to playing in Canada, he will get relegated to a “backup” role. I think Pedroia will get voted in as the starter because of the Fenway following.
Not much to really say about Shortstop this year. Derek Jeter in recent years hasnt deserved to be there, but with him and Jason Bartlett being the only two that have made big contributions, and Bartlett missing a couple weeks, I think Jeter actually earns the starting spot he will receive.
At 3rd we have Evan Longoria torching the competition in votes, as he should be. He has had a solid season up to this point and deserves to be starting. As big of an ARod fan as I am, I in no way shape or form think he belongs #2 in votes. Inge and Lowell both belong above him, and if ARod gets in the All-Star game, I think he should sit it out.
In the outfield the usual suspect is in the top three in votes, #2 to be exact…Ichiro Suzuki. Will this guy ever slow down? I’d say no. He’s the best hitter in the game since Tony Gwynn and the best fielder since a prime Ken Griffey Jr. Once again he will be starting and he belongs there. Jason Bay is first in votes and he belongs there as well. My prediction for the 3rd outfielder is Torii Hunter who is currently in 4th in votes behind another one of my favs Josh Hamilton. Hamilton is a great player but he has had a down year and been injured a little too frequent. Hunter has had a solid year and deserves to man center in the All-Star Game.
Now on to the National League. First of at catcher we have Yadier Molina leading the way over Brian McCann. I think Molina will hold on and be the starter even though I would argue that his older brother Bengie belongs there.
At 1st there isnt much too say.Albert Pujols is the most dangerous hitter in baseball and has a HUGE lead in votes. He most definately will be starting at first and will stay there.
2nd base there is a big lead for Chase Utley and I believe he will stay there. He’s had a solid season so far and is deserving of the nod.
A position that I would’ve thought there would be a closer race, 3rd base isnt as close as I thought it’d be. David Wright has about a 700k lead over Chipper Jones and Ryan Zimmerman. Im a big fan of Wright but I think Zimmerman has had a better year so far. Wright will be the starter at 3rd and Zimmerman should make it as a reserve.
Hanley Ramirez is the leading vote getter at shortstop and he should be. He’s been solid for the Fish Sticks and has been the most consistent shortstop in the NL. I think he’ll hold off a run from Rollins (who has been irrelevant this yr) and get the starting nod.
In the outfield its been a mess. 3 of the top 4 have either been hurt or slumping. Ibanez definately deserves to start despite the injury as his season has been magnificent. Beltran on the other hand? No. Soriano has been slumping all season and shouldnt be 4th in votes. I think the top 3 vote getters will be Ibanez,Braun and Soriano. An All Star outfield for sure, but not really an “All-Star” outfield.
Darren